The largest migration on Earth happens every night Image: NOAA Photo Library (CC BY 2.0)

The largest migration on Earth happens every night

In 1942 physicists working for the University of California Division of War Research were testing sonar off San Diego when their echo sounders showed a seafloor at about 300 m where the chart said the water was far deeper. The false bottom was there every day, and it moved: up towards the surface at dusk, down again at dawn. They called it the deep scattering layer, and for a few years nobody was sure whether it was a physical layer in the water or something alive. The biologist Martin Johnson settled the question in 1946 by sampling it with nets, and what came up was animals.

What the layer is made of

The echo comes mostly from gas. A fish's swim bladder is a bubble, and a bubble a few millimetres across reflects sound at the frequencies sonar uses far more strongly than the flesh around it. The strongest scatterers in the layer are therefore small fishes with swim bladders, above all the lanternfishes of the family Myctophidae, about 250 species of fish a few centimetres long with rows of light organs along their bellies. With them travel the bristlemouths of the genus Cyclothone, which are the most numerous vertebrates on Earth, the hatchetfishes, krill, shrimps, squids, and siphonophores whose gas floats also ring on sonar.

How much of it there is remains an open question. Net surveys in the 1970s gave a global biomass of mesopelagic fish of about one billion tonnes. In 2014 Xabier Irigoien and colleagues, using echo sounders on a circumnavigation by the Spanish Malaspina expedition, argued in Nature Communications that nets had missed most of the fish and that the true figure was closer to ten billion tonnes, more than ten times the mass of all the fish humans catch in a year. The acoustic estimate has its own uncertainties, because not every echo is a fish, and the honest range today runs over an order of magnitude. Whatever the number, it is the largest stock of vertebrates on the planet and almost none of it has ever been fished.

Why they move

The twilight zone, between 200 and 1,000 m, has very little light and very little food of its own. The surface has food and predators that hunt by sight. The migration is a compromise between the two: spend the day in the dark where nothing can see you, and come up at night to eat where the plankton is. A lanternfish typically rises from 400 or 500 m to the top 100 m at dusk and returns at dawn, a round trip of nearly a kilometre for an animal that would fit in a matchbox.

The cue is light. The animals follow a fixed light level, an isolume, as it moves up and down through the water with the setting and rising sun. Light falls off exponentially with depth, and in clear ocean water with an attenuation coefficient of 0.04 per metre, one metre of descent removes about 4 per cent of it. At 500 m the remaining fraction of surface light is \(e^{-0.04 \times 500} = e^{-20}\), about two parts in a billion, which is roughly the brightness of a moonless, starlit night at the surface. That is the darkness the migrators choose to spend the day in. On nights with a full moon the layer stays deeper, and during a solar eclipse it has been watched starting upwards in the middle of the day.

A worked number

Take a lanternfish of 6 cm that climbs 500 m in an hour at dusk. Its speed is 500 m divided by 3,600 s, about 14 cm per second, or a little over two body lengths a second, which is a comfortable cruising pace for a small fish. The cost of the climb is modest compared with the gain of a night's feeding in water with ten or a hundred times the density of copepods. Going down is cheaper, and some species simply stop swimming and sink.

Not every animal makes the full trip. Many lanternfishes migrate on some nights and not others, and a part of each population stays deep. The ones that do migrate are among the fastest-swimming animals of their size over a day, and they do it twice.

What they carry down

The migration moves more than animals. Everything a lanternfish eats at the surface at night is digested at depth during the day, and what it excretes, respires, and eventually becomes when it dies stays in the twilight zone, far below the layer that exchanges gas with the air. This is a pump for carbon. Models of the process put the amount transported by the migrators at somewhere around 10 to 20 per cent of the carbon that sinks passively as marine snow, with some estimates higher, and it delivers that carbon to depths from which it will not return to the atmosphere for decades to centuries. The twilight zone's role in the carbon cycle is the reason the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution set up a dedicated research programme on it, and the reason proposals to fish it for fish meal are watched closely.

Seeing it for yourself

Any fish finder on a small boat over deep water will show the layer, and so will the echograms published by research vessels. NOAA Ocean Exploration keeps a short explanation with an example. The thing to look for is a band at 300 to 500 m during the day that smears upwards in the hour after sunset until it merges with the surface noise, and a second, fainter band of animals that did not bother to move.

Unit 13 of the Marine Biology Masterclass covers the twilight zone, the scattering layer, the light calculation above, the counter-illumination that lets a hatchetfish hide from below, and the biology of bioluminescence. Unit 11 treats the daily migration alongside the seasonal migrations of whales and tuna, and Unit 8 fits it into the ocean's carbon budget. The full outline is in the curriculum.

Study the ocean properly

The Marine Biology Masterclass: weekly units, quizzes, a final exam, and a certificate.
About the program